Very good. I learned a lot. Prohibition was impossible until they passed the amendment that allowed a federal income tax. (Up to 70% of the U.S. budget came from alcohol excise taxes before then!)
You’d think modern politicians might begin to see drug legalization as a massive tax windfall. Calling all you deficit hawks…
.
.
The problem is that quite a large percentage of Know Nothing prohibitionists are innumerate and would rather spend $10 to keep people in prison or under supervision that to spend $1 giving people that they despise a hand up. It’s amazing how many of them think that people have a say in how their tax money gets spent. I’d sure like to decide how my tax money is spent. Mr. Hussein would still be President of Iraq if that had happened before the Dork President and his faithful ward Dick pillaged the Treasury.
What I want to know is, if these people think that life on “welfare” is all puppies and sunshine then why the heck aren’t they quitting their jobs and signing up, at least a percentage? Living on $900 a month and $200 in food stamps isn’t putting on the Ritz by any stretch of the imagination.
Without ever mentioning marijuana,,even to an uneducated on the WoD viewer,the parallels between then and now stand out like a sore thumb.
You can watch the first episode at pbs.com I believe.
The more things change, the more they stay the same. Was that script written in 1976 or 2011? Substitute “terrorists” for Russians, strike inflation and use national debt, and who the hell could say without checking the copyright date?
a senior moment here… fell asleep on the couch while watching it. But excellent stuff! I think I saw most of it…
Eager for the next installment.
The historical photos and film footage all of outstanding quality, the details of the narrative very informative and I’ll wager this will change more than one mind about the WOD.
If you’ve read Daniel Okrent’s book Last Call, there was little in there that was new, but it was put together beautifully to tell the story of how America came to have Prohibition. The part that remains the most striking to me is the anti-German sentiment. People of German descent are so unmistakably American today that seeing them treated in the late 1800s and early 1900s the way we treat Mexicans and Muslims today was fascinating.
And yeah, the “Great War” obviously played a big part in that.
If you get a chance, check out Ken Burns on the Daily Show. After describing some of the horrors of prohibition, he makes a comment about things being the same today. It’s pretty obvious what the message of this series is.
The main point I got from the second episode was that a large segment of the population thought Prohibition was a joke from the very beginning. A huge percentage of the (male) population imbibed and a good chunk of them had no intention of ever quitting. Plus the Republican administration had no desire to fund an army of police to enforce the surprisingly draconian Volstead Act, and the state and local governments weren’t going to spend money on it either. It was doomed from the very beginning.
Contrast that with Nixon’s “War on Drugs.” The vast majority of Americans weren’t using illegal drugs. The idea that the small minority who used them could be made to stop must have seemed relatively reasonable at the time. That’s why Prohibition II has been of such a longer duration than the original. It has taken four decades of mass incarceration, family destruction and a trillion dollars up in smoke for people to finally realize that you can’t even put a small amount of the toothpaste back into the tube.
What an excellent documentary. It is just stunning how closely todays WoD and alcohol prohibition parallel one another. Through the entire show I kept thinking how one could insert the word “drugs” for “alcohol” and have a documentary about todays WoD. Not only the prohibition part but the political atmosphere also. The only difference I found was the extent of the scofflaws. A very informing piece of work. Recommend highly its viewing.
Servetus on Where is he getting his data?: “Psilocybin beats a top selling SSRI by 2-to-1 in remission rates for treatment of major depression: Psilocybin, the active compound…” Apr 17, 13:21
Carlyle Moulton on Is Joe Biden an old dog?: “Every nation has underclasses that must be controlled. The main mechanism of control is the criminal law so every nation…” Apr 17, 11:24
NorCalNative on Afghanistan’s farmers go solar: “Biden may be a career politician with his lips placed firmly on the anus of Christian Imperialism but at least…” Apr 11, 16:21
Graveyard shift on Afghanistan’s farmers go solar: ““..the British pulled 400,000 of their troops out of Normandy in just ten days…” and that was under assault from…” Apr 11, 12:15
Servetus on Where is he getting his data?: “Medicinal treatments for opioid use disorder are less likely to be available to those having had contact with the criminal…” Apr 8, 15:58
Servetus on Where is he getting his data?: “Shane Vaughn (AKA Professor Toto) proclaims right wingers are flush with cash because the left is full of “young folks”…” Apr 6, 16:52
it’s been on about 10 minutes here and I’m loving it… I’ll post again when it’s over. Education is a great thing.
Very good. I learned a lot. Prohibition was impossible until they passed the amendment that allowed a federal income tax. (Up to 70% of the U.S. budget came from alcohol excise taxes before then!)
You’d think modern politicians might begin to see drug legalization as a massive tax windfall. Calling all you deficit hawks…
.
.
The problem is that quite a large percentage of Know Nothing prohibitionists are innumerate and would rather spend $10 to keep people in prison or under supervision that to spend $1 giving people that they despise a hand up. It’s amazing how many of them think that people have a say in how their tax money gets spent. I’d sure like to decide how my tax money is spent. Mr. Hussein would still be President of Iraq if that had happened before the Dork President and his faithful ward Dick pillaged the Treasury.
What I want to know is, if these people think that life on “welfare” is all puppies and sunshine then why the heck aren’t they quitting their jobs and signing up, at least a percentage? Living on $900 a month and $200 in food stamps isn’t putting on the Ritz by any stretch of the imagination.
Without ever mentioning marijuana,,even to an uneducated on the WoD viewer,the parallels between then and now stand out like a sore thumb.
You can watch the first episode at pbs.com I believe.
Thanks, Clay. I missed it. I’ll find some time today to watch so I can get up to speed for the next installment!
Excellent!
“The devil would turn out to be in the details!”
http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition/watch-video/#id=2082675582
Were not as malleable as we used to be.The wool the governments been pulling over our eyes has worn thin.
.
.
Well you see, I’m mad as hell and I’m not going to take it anymore. I’m a human being goddammit. My life has value.
There’s a lot of us who are at this point. Fiction in the link below, very, very real where I’m sitting.
Union Broadcasting System Evening News:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGIY5Vyj4YM
The more things change, the more they stay the same. Was that script written in 1976 or 2011? Substitute “terrorists” for Russians, strike inflation and use national debt, and who the hell could say without checking the copyright date?
Here. I’ll link it again:
http://www.livestream.com/globalrevolution
http://occupywallst.org/
http://occupyeverything.org/
There are ALOT of us. 116 cities and counting.
a senior moment here… fell asleep on the couch while watching it. But excellent stuff! I think I saw most of it…
Eager for the next installment.
The historical photos and film footage all of outstanding quality, the details of the narrative very informative and I’ll wager this will change more than one mind about the WOD.
The morons in govt won`t get it. The connection. Get out the guillotine.
If you’ve read Daniel Okrent’s book Last Call, there was little in there that was new, but it was put together beautifully to tell the story of how America came to have Prohibition. The part that remains the most striking to me is the anti-German sentiment. People of German descent are so unmistakably American today that seeing them treated in the late 1800s and early 1900s the way we treat Mexicans and Muslims today was fascinating.
And yeah, the “Great War” obviously played a big part in that.
If you get a chance, check out Ken Burns on the Daily Show. After describing some of the horrors of prohibition, he makes a comment about things being the same today. It’s pretty obvious what the message of this series is.
You can watch it on the ‘net here:
http://video.pbs.org/video/17759137/
The main point I got from the second episode was that a large segment of the population thought Prohibition was a joke from the very beginning. A huge percentage of the (male) population imbibed and a good chunk of them had no intention of ever quitting. Plus the Republican administration had no desire to fund an army of police to enforce the surprisingly draconian Volstead Act, and the state and local governments weren’t going to spend money on it either. It was doomed from the very beginning.
Contrast that with Nixon’s “War on Drugs.” The vast majority of Americans weren’t using illegal drugs. The idea that the small minority who used them could be made to stop must have seemed relatively reasonable at the time. That’s why Prohibition II has been of such a longer duration than the original. It has taken four decades of mass incarceration, family destruction and a trillion dollars up in smoke for people to finally realize that you can’t even put a small amount of the toothpaste back into the tube.
What an excellent documentary. It is just stunning how closely todays WoD and alcohol prohibition parallel one another. Through the entire show I kept thinking how one could insert the word “drugs” for “alcohol” and have a documentary about todays WoD. Not only the prohibition part but the political atmosphere also. The only difference I found was the extent of the scofflaws. A very informing piece of work. Recommend highly its viewing.